Tesla Sued in UK in Fight Over Charging Stations rollout
27 Mars 2015 - Automotive News
Tesla Motors was sued in London in a dispute over whether the company interfered with a competitor’s plan to rollout electric-car chargers at UK highway rest stops.
Judge Vivien Rose on Wednesday ordered Tesla to search for documents about internal meetings and discussions with other companies about setting up its own network of chargers for its electric cars, which start at about 50,000 pounds ($74,450) in the UK.
Ecotricity Group says Tesla negotiated with companies including Tesco after it had already held talks.
“There do seem to have been meetings in October 2014” with motorway service providers, Rose said. “Something more is needed to be absolutely sure that there’s nothing more.”
The lawsuit reflects the jostling among carmakers and charging network providers seeking a share of the developing market for electric vehicles and the infrastructure to serve them.
Tesla, which is spending billions of dollars on the world’s largest battery factory, has identified the European market as important to its growth.
Ecotricity says in its suit that Tesla used its confidential information and tried to induce highway rest stop companies such as Welcome Break Group to breach agreements with Ecotricity for exclusive charging points last year as Tesla introduced the Model S in the UK.
Tesla won orders against Ecotricity including requiring it to produce financial records, strategy documents and evidence of any loss, said spokesman Ricardo Reyes. “The main focus of the hearing was our antitrust claim against Ecotricity and we won the vast majority of the matters before the court,” he said.
Tesla countersued Ecotricity and accused the UK renewable-energy supplier of acting abusively in its dominant position as a supplier. Tesla denied in court documents that it misused any confidential information Ecotricity gave it or that it tried to induce companies to break contracts with Ecotricity.
Rose declined to force Tesla to search for documents containing certain search terms and initials that Ecotricity had specified or to produce records of telephone calls with Welcome Break, which Ecotricity was seeking.
The case is Ecotricity Group Ltd. v. Tesla Motors Inc., UK High Court of Justice, Chancery Division.